Home Archives$600 Million: What Do We Know? – Not Enough

$600 Million: What Do We Know? – Not Enough

by Ron Diner
St. Petersburg waterfront with infrastructure pipes, engineering plans and a Referendum #1 ballot illustrating questions about the proposed 0 million infrastructure bond.

This is the second in a series about the St. Petersburg bond referendum that would authorize the city to borrow as much as $600 million for stormwater, wastewater and drinking-water infrastructure.

In my first post, I said I didn’t know whether voters should vote yes or no.

I still don’t.

But I am extremely concerned – in fact, I am fairly certain – that the information we need to evaluate this $600 million proposal won’t be available in time. Mail ballots are already going out, and people are beginning to vote.

So what do we do if there isn’t enough time to get the information, have it independently reviewed and understand what we are actually being asked to approve?

Would it be better to vote no—not because we oppose investing in our infrastructure, but because we would rather have the City do this right and come back to the voters with the information needed to make an informed decision?

And as best I can determine, there are ways for the City to come back to voters with a more complete proposal within a reasonable period of time, without significantly delaying the infrastructure work.

But before reaching that conclusion, let’s look at what we know.

What Do We Know So Far?

 
  • The City says it has approximately $4.4 billion in water, wastewater and stormwater capital needs through 2050. Approximately $2.7 billion of that is identified as priority resiliency projects.

  • The City now wants voters to authorize $600 million in new borrowing, which it estimates will cost taxpayers approximately $1.1 billion when you add interest.

  • The principal justification for borrowing the money now is to get important projects completed sooner. The City has said the $2.7 billion SPAR program could be completed in approximately 19 years rather than 24 years.

Maybe getting these projects completed five years sooner is worth the additional cost.

But how do we know?

To answer that, we need to know:

  • Which projects would be accelerated

  • How much sooner they would be completed

  • What they are expected to cost, and

  • What taxpayers would gain by completing them sooner.

What Information Don’t We Have?

 
  • We don’t have a complete project-level list showing what makes up the $4.4 billion in capital needs, what makes up the $2.7 billion SPAR program, and, most importantly, which projects the City expects to fund with the $600 million voters are being asked to authorize.

  • We don’t have a clear picture of when those projects would be completed without the $600 million, when they would be completed with it, and what residents would gain from completing them sooner.

Those are the details that would allow us to evaluate the basic question:

What are we getting for the $600 million plus the $500 million interest cost – and what difference will spending it sooner actually make?

What About Citizen Oversight?

The City has said that if the GO bond passes, a Citizen Advisory Committee will be established to advise on the priority of projects funded with the $600 million.

But there is nothing in the bond resolution that requires a citizen advisory committee (or an independent review of the projects).

My understanding is that the City Council discussed a a citizen-led Resiliency Advisory Board, but it was only a referral to a Council committee to discuss.

And even if an advisory committee is ultimately created, I have seen nothing that establishes that it would include independent experts in engineering, infrastructure, finance or resiliency who could evaluate the City’s plans and assumptions. We also don’t know who would serve on it, what it would actually review, or how its work and recommendations would be reported to the public.

But whoever serves on it, how could the committee meaningfully evaluate priorities without the same information we are talking about here—a complete list of the projects, their estimated costs, their schedules and the benefits expected from completing them sooner?

More importantly, an advisory committee created after the referendum would come after voters have already authorized the $600 million. Independent review of the projects, costs and expected benefits would be most useful before voters are asked to make that decision.

Where Does That Leave Us?

It leaves us with the City not providing enough information to know how to vote. Period.

I have asked the city for the information I believe voters need to evaluate the proposed $600 bond. The city has provided some of that information, but important gaps remain. Using the information the City provided, I created a project-level spreadsheet showing what I have been able to determine so far. I sent it to the city and asked them to review it to make sure I have correctly interpreted their information and to fill in the information that is missing.

I have asked the City to tell me by noon Tuesday whether it intends to provide the additional information I have requested and, if so, when.

I hope it does. And if I receive it, I will do my best to organize it and share what I learn.

But there is a limit to what I can do. I am one person trying to understand a complicated infrastructure and financing proposal. I am not an engineer or an infrastructure expert, and I don’t have a team of independent experts evaluating the projects, their costs and the benefits of completing them sooner.

St. Petersburg unquestionably has serious infrastructure needs. And completing important resiliency projects sooner may well be worth paying for.

But before voters authorize $600 million in borrowing that the City estimates could ultimately require $1.1 billion in repayment, I think we ought to be able to answer two simple questions:

What exactly are we buying?

And what do we gain by buying it sooner?

That’s what I’m trying to find out.

You may also like